How it works
Each answer gets 0 (never), 1 (about weekly) or 2 (most days) and is multiplied by how the provider’s own pricing page words that feature for the Free plan: ×0 if Free includes it, ×1 if Free says “limited”, ×2 if it is only in paid plans. “Limit reached” messages always count ×2, because they are the clearest sign you are outgrowing Free. Projects: Claude Free allows up to 5, so “more than 5” adds 4 points for Claude; ChatGPT lists Projects on all plans. Claude does not generate images on any plan, so images add nothing for Claude. Score 0–2: Free is probably enough; 3–6: borderline; 7 or more: compare paid plans. The thresholds are our own rule of thumb, not the providers’. Feature wording was checked on 14 Nov 2026; providers change their plans often. A rough self-check, not advice from OpenAI or Anthropic.
How the Free plans are worded (official pricing and help pages, checked 14 Nov 2026)
| Need | ChatGPT Free | Claude Free |
|---|---|---|
| File uploads | “Limited messages with uploads” | Included (file creation & code execution) |
| Research reports | “Limited deep research” | Not in Free (Research is for paid plans) |
| Images | “Limited image creation” | No image generation on any plan |
| Projects | On all plans | Up to 5 Projects |
| Coding tool | Not scored here | Claude Code is not in Free |
| Voice | “Limited voice chats” | Voice mode on all plans |
| Earlier chats | “Limited memory and context” | Memory included; chat search on paid plans |
| Usage | “Unlimited text chats subject to abuse guardrails” | Pro gives “More usage than Free” |
⚠ Estimates for information only — not financial advice.
FAQ
Why does my score say “borderline”?
You use some things that Free limits. Use Free for a normal week and note each time you are blocked; if it happens on days you really need the tool, a paid plan is worth it.
Is this a recommendation to buy?
No. It only matches your answers to the providers’ own descriptions of the Free plan. Plans change, so check the pricing page before paying.
Checked 14 Nov 2026. OpenAI, chatgpt.com/pricing (plan feature lists). Anthropic, claude.com/pricing (Free includes / not included), support.claude.com articles 9002504 (images), 11817273 (memory and chat search) and 11088861 (Research). All checked 14 Nov 2026. Scoring rule: our own.