Understanding the tax-equivalent yield calculator — concept and principle
Interest from most US municipal bonds is free of federal income tax, so a lower municipal yield can be worth more than a higher taxable yield. The tax-equivalent yield tells you what a taxable bond would have to pay to leave you with the same income after tax.
How it is calculated
- Combined tax rate on taxable interest = federal rate + net investment income tax + state rate (state tax simply added, ignoring any deduction).
- Tax-equivalent yield = tax-free yield ÷ (1 − combined rate).
- If the municipal bond is from another state, your state usually taxes its interest, so its yield is first reduced by the state rate.
- After-tax yield of a taxable bond = taxable yield × (1 − combined rate).
The principle
What matters to an investor is the income kept after tax. A taxable bond loses part of its interest to tax; a tax-free bond does not. Dividing the tax-free yield by the share of taxable interest you keep, (1 − t), gives the pre-tax yield that would leave you with the same amount. The higher your tax bracket, the more a tax exemption is worth, which is why municipal bonds appeal most to high earners.
Worked example
Default inputs: municipal yield 4%, federal rate 32%, net investment income tax 3.8%, no state tax, bond free of state tax, taxable alternative 5.5%.
- Combined tax rate = 32 + 3.8 + 0 = 35.8%.
- Tax-equivalent yield = 4 ÷ (1 − 0.358) ≈ 6.23%.
- After-tax yield of the tax-free bond = 4%.
- After-tax yield of the 5.5% taxable bond = 5.5 × 0.642 ≈ 3.53%.
- Tax-free bond is better after tax, by 0.47 points.
| Yield of the tax-free (municipal) bond (%) | Tax-equivalent yield |
|---|---|
| 1 | 1.56% |
| 2 | 3.12% |
| 3 | 4.67% |
| 4 | 6.23% |
| 5 | 7.79% |
| 6 | 9.35% |
| 8 | 12.46% |
How to read the result
If the taxable bond yields less than the tax-equivalent yield, the municipal bond leaves you with more after tax. Compare bonds of similar credit quality and maturity; a higher yield may reflect higher risk. Investors in low tax brackets may find taxable bonds better.
Common mistakes
- Using your average tax rate instead of your marginal rate.
- Forgetting state tax on out-of-state municipal bonds.
- Ignoring the alternative minimum tax on some private-activity municipal bonds.
- Comparing bonds with different credit ratings or call features.
Frequently asked questions
What is the tax-equivalent yield formula?
Tax-free yield ÷ (1 − tax rate).
Are municipal bonds always tax-free?
Interest on most is exempt from federal income tax, but state tax and the AMT may apply in some cases.
Which tax rate should I use?
Your marginal rate, the rate on your next dollar of income, including any extra tax on investment income.
Sources: FINRA, "Municipal Bonds" investor guidance (tax-equivalent yield) · MSRB, Electronic Municipal Market Access (EMMA) education center